(ג) חמשה תלמידים היו לו לרבן יוחנן בן זכאי לכולן קרא להן שמות. לאליעזר בן הורקנוס קרא בור סיד שאינו מאבד טיפה קנקן זפותה שמשמרת את יינה. ליהושע בן חנניה קרא לו חוט המשולש לא במהרה ינתק.
Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakai had five students, and he had names by which he referred to each of them. He referred to Eliezer ben Horkanos as a reinforced cistern that does not lose a drop, and a solid jug that protects its water. He referred to Yehoshua ben Hananiah as a three-stringed rope which will not easily be severed.
What was the beginning of Rabbi Eliezer ben Horkanos? He was twenty-two years old and had never studied Torah. One day, he said, "I'm going to go learn Torah from Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakai". His father Horkanos said to him, "you can't go there to learn until you've plowed the whole field". He woke up first thing in the morning and plowed the whole field. Then, he went on his way; he didn't have anywhere to go and didn't eat anything from Friday afternoon until Motzei Shabbat. When he went on his way after Shabbat, he saw a clump of dirt and put in his mouth. Some say it was not dirt, but was rather cow dung.
He continued on his way and stopped at an inn to sleep, then continued until he made it to Yochanan ben Zakai's Beit Midrash in Yerushalayim. Eventually he opened his mouth and a terrible smell emanated from his mouth. Yochanan ben Zakai said to him, "Eliezer my son, have you not eaten anything today?" He remained silent. Yochanan ben Zakai asked him again, but again he did not reply. Yochanan ben Zakai sent a messenger to the inn where Eliezer was staying, and asked them, "Did Eliezer eat anything at your inn?" They replied, "No, we assumed maybe he was eating by you". He replied, "I assumed that he was eating by you". Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakai called Rabbi Eliezer and said to him, "the same mouth that a bad odor came out this morning will be the mouth from which will flow amazing Torah knowledge."
מימי לא קדמני אדם בבית המדרש ולא ישנתי בבית המדרש לא שינת קבע ולא שינת עראי ולא הנחתי אדם בבית המדרש ויצאתי ולא שחתי שיחת חולין ולא אמרתי דבר שלא שמעתי מפי רבי מעולם
(Rabbi Eliezer said): In all my days, a person never came before me to the House of Study, And neither did I sleep in the House of Study, neither a permanent sleep nor a temporary sleep, and never did I leave a man in the House of Study and exit, and never did I converse in regular conversation, and I never said anything which I did not hear from my teacher at any time."
רַבִּי יְהוֹשֻׁעַ בֶּן חֲנַנְיָה, אַשְׁרֵי יוֹלַדְתּוֹ.
Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya--happy is the one who gave birth to him!
(ד) אַשְׁרֵי יוֹלַדְתּוֹ. מְאֻשָּׁר בְּמִדּוֹת טוֹבוֹת עַד שֶׁכָּל הָעוֹלָם אוֹמְרִים עָלָיו אַשְׁרֵי מִי שֶׁיְּלָדַתּוּ. וְיֵשׁ אוֹמְרִים, עַל שֵׁם שֶׁהִיא גָּרְמָה לוֹ שֶׁיְּהֵא חָכָם, שֶׁהָיְתָה מְחַזֶּרֶת עַל כָּל בָּתֵּי מִדְרָשׁוֹת שֶׁבְּעִירָהּ וְאוֹמֶרֶת לָהֶם בְּבַקָּשָׁה מִכֶּם בַּקְּשׁוּ רַחֲמִים עַל הָעֻבָּר הַזֶּה שֶׁבְּמֵעַי שֶׁיִּהְיֶה חָכָם, וּמִיּוֹם שֶׁנּוֹלַד לֹא הוֹצִיאָה עֲרַשְׂתּוֹ מִבֵּית הַמִּדְרָשׁ כְּדֵי שֶׁלֹּא יִכָּנְסוּ בְּאָזְנָיו אֶלָּא דִּבְרֵי תּוֹרָה:
(4) "happy is the one who gave birth to him": Rendered happy by good character traits is one who the whole world says about him, "happy is the one who gave birth to him." And some say, because she caused him to be a sage. For she would go out to all of the study halls in her town and say to them, "I request from you that you should seek mercy (pray) for this embryo that is in my innards, that he should be a sage." And from the day that he was born, she did not remove his crib from the study hall, so that only words of Torah would enter his ears.
ר' יהושע נסיב כהנתא חלש אמר לא ניחא ליה לאהרן דאדבק בזרעיה דהוי ליה חתנא
Rabbi Yehoshua married a kohen's daughter. Soon afterward she became sick (and never recovered). When she fell ill, he said, "I guess Aharon does not want me to marry his descendants; I guess he doesn't want a son-in-law like me
ר' יהושע...היה אומר חסיד שוטה ורשע ערום ואשה פרושה ומכות פרושין הרי אלו מבלי עולם
Rabbi Yehoshua... would say: A foolish man of piety, and a conniving wicked person, and an abstinent woman [perusha], and those who injure themselves out of false abstinence; all these are people who erode the world.
Those who injure themselves out of abstinence: It explains in the Gemara that these are people who hit themselves to show how humble and modest they are
§ The Sages taught: The verse states: “Justice, justice, shall you follow.” This teaches that one should follow the best, most prestigious, court of the generation. For example, follow after Rabbi Eliezer to Lod, after Rabban Yoḥanan ben Zakkai to Beror Ḥayil.
שאלו את רבי אליעזר חלה מהו שירכיבהו על כתפו אמר להם יכול הוא להרכיב אני ואתם... מהו לסוד את ביתו מהו לסוד את קברו לא מפני שהפליגן בדברים אלא מפני שלא אמר דבר שלא שמע מפי רבו מעולם
§ Apropos this discussion, the Gemara mentions that the students once asked Rabbi Eliezer: If the goat became ill, what is the halakha with regard to whether the escort may carry it on his shoulder? He said to them: That goat can carry me and you, meaning the goat designated healthy was unlikely to become ill. Rabbi Eliezer thereby avoided the question....They asked him: What is the halakha with regard to whether it is permitted to plaster one’s house after the destruction of the Temple? Rabbi Eliezer responded: What is the halakha with regard to plastering one’s grave? The Gemara explains: It was not because he was distancing them with words, and made irrelevant statements because he did not know the answers to these questions. Rather, Rabbi Eliezer responded in this way because he never said anything that he did not hear from the mouth of his teacher.
There was another incident involving Rabbi Eliezer, who descended to serve as prayer leader before the ark on a fast day. And he recited twenty-four blessings, but he was not answered. Rabbi Akiva descended before the ark after him and said: Our Father, our King, we have no king other than You. Our Father, our King, for Your sake, have mercy on us. And rain immediately fell. The Sages were whispering among themselves that Rabbi Akiva was answered while his teacher, Rabbi Eliezer, was not. A Divine Voice emerged and said: It is not because this Sage, Rabbi Akiva, is greater than that one, Rabbi Eliezer, but that this one is forgiving, and that one is not forgiving. God responded to Rabbi Akiva’s forgiving nature in kind by sending rain.
Rabbi Eliezer raised his two arms and placed them on his heart, and he said: Woe to you, my two arms, as they are like two Torah scrolls that are now being rolled up, and will never be opened again. I have learned much Torah, and I have taught much Torah. I have learned much Torah, and I have not taken away from my teachers, i.e., I have not received from their wisdom, even like a dog lapping from the sea. I have taught much Torah, and my students have taken away from me, i.e., they have received from my wisdom, only like the tiny amount that a paintbrush removes from a tube of paint.
מרגלא בפומייהו דרבנן דיבנה אני בריה וחברי בריה אני מלאכתי בעיר והוא מלאכתו בשדה אני משכים למלאכתי והוא משכים למלאכתו כשם שהוא אינו מתגדר במלאכתי כך אני איני מתגדר במלאכתו ושמא תאמר אני מרבה והוא ממעיט שנינו אחד המרבה ואחד הממעיט ובלבד שיכוין לבו לשמים.
It was a favourite saying of the Rabbis of Jabneh (when Yehoshua ben Hanania was in charge) : I am a creature [of God] and my neighbour is also His creature ; my work is in the city and his in the field ; I rise early to my work and he rises early to his. As he cannot excel in my work, so I cannot excel in his work. But perhaps thou sayest, "I do great things and he small things"! We have learnt that [it matters not whether] one does much or little, if only he direct his heart to Heaven.
תנו רבנן כשחרב הבית בשניה רבו פרושין בישראל שלא לאכול בשר ושלא לשתות יין נטפל להן ר' יהושע אמר להן בני מפני מה אי אתם אוכלין בשר ואין אתם שותין יין? אמרו לו נאכל בשר שממנו מקריבין על גבי מזבח ועכשיו בטל נשתה יין שמנסכין על גבי המזבח ועכשיו בטל. אמר להם א"כ לחם לא נאכל שכבר בטלו מנחות אפשר בפירות פירות לא נאכל שכבר בטלו בכורים אפשר בפירות אחרים מים לא נשתה שכבר בטל ניסוך המים שתקו אמר להן בני בואו ואומר לכם שלא להתאבל כל עיקר אי אפשר שכבר נגזרה גזרה ולהתאבל יותר מדאי אי אפשר שאין גוזרין גזירה על הצבור אא"כ רוב צבור יכולין לעמוד בה
Our Rabbis taught: “When the Temple was destroyed for the second time, ascetics who would not eat meat or drink wine increased in Israel: Rabbi Joshua approached them, saying: ‘My sons, why do you neither eat meat nor drink wine?’ They replied, ‘How could we eat meat when it was once sacrificed on the Altar which has now ceased to be?’ He replied ‘In that case let me refrain also from bread because the meal offerings have ceased.’ They replied ‘Yes, we could live by eating fruit.’ Joshua said: ‘No, we should not eat fruit because the offering of first fruits has also ceased. Oh, and we probably shouldn't have water any more either, since we can't pour water on the altar anymore."
Rabbi Yehoshua said, "My children, come and tell everyone that your mourning should not become the "core" of your religious practice, and there shouldn't be any more decrees beyond those which have already been made. The rabbis have already passed too many decrees about mourning, and this is wrong because we should only make rules that the majority of the people would be able to handle, and we have already gone beyond what the majority of people can handle.
ר' יהושע בן חנניה הוה קאי בי קיסר אחוי ליה ההוא אפיקורוסא עמא דאהדרינהו מריה לאפיה מיניה אחוי ליה ידו נטויה עלינו אמר ליה קיסר לר' יהושע מאי אחוי לך עמא דאהדרינהו מריה לאפיה מיניה ואנא מחוינא ליה ידו נטויה עלינו אמרו ליה לההוא מינא מאי אחויית ליה עמא דאהדרינהו מריה מיניה ומאי אחוי לך לא ידענא אמרו גברא דלא ידע מאי מחוו ליה במחוג יחוי קמי מלכא אפקוהו וקטלוהו
כי קא ניחא נפשיה דרבי יהושע בן חנניה אמרו ליה רבנן מאי תיהוי עלן מאפיקורוסין אמר להם (ירמיהו מט, ז) אבדה עצה מבנים נסרחה חכמתם כיון שאבדה עצה מבנים נסרחה חכמתן של אומות העולם ואי בעית אימא מהכא (בראשית לג, יב) ויאמר נסעה ונלכה ואלכה לנגדך
The Gemara relates: Rabbi Yehoshua ben Ḥananya was standing in the house of the Caesar. A certain heretic, who was also present, gestured to him, indicating that his was the nation whose Master, God, turned His face away from it. Rabbi Yehoshua gestured to him that His hand is outstretched over us in protection. The Caesar said to Rabbi Yehoshua: What did he gesture to you, and how did you respond? He replied: He indicated that mine is the nation whose Master turned His face from it, and I gestured to him that His hand is outstretched over us. The members of the Caesar’s household said to that heretic: What did you gesture to him? He said to them: I gestured that his is the nation whose Master has turned His face from it. They asked: And what did he gesture to you? He said to them: I don’t know; I did not understand. They said: How can a man who does not know what others gesture to him dare to gesture in the presence of the king? They took him out and killed him.
The Gemara relates: When Rabbi Yehoshua ben Ḥananya was dying, the Sages said to him: What will become of us, from the threat of the heretics, when there is no scholar like you who can refute them? He said to them that the verse states: “Is wisdom no more in Teiman? Has counsel perished from the prudent? Has their wisdom vanished?” (Jeremiah 49:7). He explained: Since counsel has perished from the prudent, from the Jewish people, the wisdom of the nations of the world has vanished as well, and there will be no superior scholars among them. And if you wish, say instead that the same idea can be derived from here: “And he said: Let us take our journey, and let us go, and I will go corresponding to you” (Genesis 33:12). Just as the Jewish people rise and fall, so too, the nations of the world simultaneously rise and fall, and they will never have an advantage.
It is taught in a baraita that Rabbi Eliezer says: It is written: “The wicked shall be turned back to the netherworld, all that nations that forget God” (Psalms 9:18). “The wicked shall be turned back to the netherworld”; these are the sinners of the Jewish people, as only the sinners are sentenced to the netherworld. “All the gentiles that forget God”; these are the sinners of the gentiles. From the fact that it is written: “All the gentiles,” it is apparent that none of the gentiles have a share in the World-to-Come. This is the statement of Rabbi Eliezer. Rabbi Yehoshua said to him: But is it stated in the verse that the sinners of the Jewish people will be like all of the gentiles? It is stated only: “All the gentiles that forget God.” Rather, the wicked shall be turned back to the netherworld, and who are they? They are all the gentiles that forget God. Gentiles who fear God do have a share in the World-to-Come.
תנו רבנן מעשה ברבי אליעזר שהיה יושב ודורש כל היום כולו בהלכות יום טוב יצתה כת ראשונה אמר הללו בעלי פטסין כת שניה אמר הללו בעלי חביות... התחילו כת ששית לצאת אמר הללו בעלי מארה נתן עיניו בתלמידים התחילו פניהם משתנין אמר להם בני לא לכם אני אומר אלא להללו שיצאו שמניחים חיי עולם ועוסקים בחיי שעה... אמר מר שמניחין חיי עולם ועוסקין בחיי שעה והא שמחת יום טוב מצוה היא רבי אליעזר לטעמיה דאמר שמחת יום טוב רשות דתניא רבי אליעזר אומר אין לו לאדם ביום טוב אלא או אוכל ושותה או יושב ושונה רבי יהושע אומר חלקהו חציו לה' וחציו לכם
§ The Sages taught in a baraita: There was an incident involving Rabbi Eliezer, who was sitting and lecturing about the halakhot of the Festival throughout the entire Festival day. When the first group left in the middle of his lecture, he said: These must be owners of extremely large jugs [pittasin], who apparently have huge containers of wine awaiting them as well as a comparable amount of food, and they have left the house of study out of a craving for their food. After a while a second group departed. He said: These are owners of barrels, which are smaller than pittasin...When a sixth group began to leave, he became upset that the house of study was being left almost completely empty and said: These are owners of a curse; i.e., they obviously do not have anything at home, so why are they leaving? He cast his eyes upon the students remaining in the house of study. Immediately, their faces began to change color out of shame, as they feared he was referring to them and that perhaps they should have departed along with the others instead of staying. He said to them: My sons, I did not say that about you but about those who left, because they abandon the eternal life of Torah and engage in the temporary life of eating... The Gemara clarifies this baraita. The Master said above: Because they abandon eternal life and engage in temporary life. The Gemara wonders at this: But isn’t the joy of the Festival itself a mitzva and therefore part of eternal life? The Gemara answers: Rabbi Eliezer conforms to his standard line of reasoning, as he said: Physical joy on a Festival is merely optional. As it is taught in a baraita that Rabbi Eliezer says: A person has no way of fulfilling the mitzva of a Festival correctly apart from either eating and drinking, thereby fulfilling the mitzva of joy in a completely physical manner, or sitting and studying Torah, thereby emphasizing only the spiritual; and those who did not engage in Torah study to the fullest extent acted inappropriately. Rabbi Yehoshua says: There is no need for such a dichotomy; rather, simply divide it: Half to God, Torah study, and half to yourselves, engaging in eating, drinking, and other pleasurable activities.