Altruistic donation of organs from living donors is widely accepted as a virtue and even encouraged as a duty. What is the Jewish legal (halachic) position on this issue? The conclusion is that altruistic donation is praiseworthy but in no way obligatory.
There are three fundamental problems concerning the halachic aspects of transplantation from living donors: 1) The danger to the donor; 2) donation under coercion; and 3) sale of organs and tissues. I will address the first of these and offer the others for your consideration.
-
A donor who gives a kidney in order to prolong the life of another or to improve his quality of life fulfills a mitzvah of great merit.
-
Nevertheless, even though the donor’s life is not thereby shortened, there is no halachic obligation to donate a kidney.40–43
Organ Transplants from Living Donors – Halachic Aspects*
Mordechai Halperin, M.D.**
40. Rabbi Waldenberg EY. Tzitz Eliezer 10:25, ch. 7.
41. Rabbi Yosef O. Kidney transplants. Diney Israel. 1976;7:25–43. Hebrew. [Google Scholar]
42. Rabbi ha-Levi CD. Organ transplants. Assia. 1983;4:255–7. Hebrew. [Google Scholar]
43. Abraham SA. Nishmat Avraham: Medical Halacha for Doctors, Nurses, Health-care Personnel and Patients. Vol. 2. New York: Mesorah Publications; 2003. p. 349. Yoreh De’ah. [Google Scholar]