*Talmud Pesachim 64b. The Talmud is referring to crowd control in the Holy Temple. I am generalizing the statement in this Dvar Torah to highlight the Divine policy shift from displaying miracles that dazzle the people into obedience, to education and psychological retraining to enlist people to freely follow.
Click the 'play' button below to listen to a recording of Rabbi Yitz Greenberg's Dvar Torah.
To all outward appearances, Parashat BeShallah is the archetype of the revelation of God to humanity through awe-inspiring miracles. The natural processes are so completely overturned that there is no room for doubt as to who is the Master of the Universe. At the same time, the parashah’s counter-narrative teaches us that divine miracle-making does not overcome the flawed character of human nature.
BeShallah starts with perhaps the most important miracle in the Bible—certainly the most celebrated—the splitting of the Reed Sea. This wondrous event enabled the Israelites to successfully complete their escape from Egypt. The stunning miracle obliterated Pharaoh’s army and the residual Egyptian capacity to re-enslave the Hebrews. If the Exodus or liberation is the core experience of Jewish history and religion, then the splitting of the sea is its climactic moment, so overwhelming that the Israelites’ anxieties and hesitations fall away. Now they know that “God is in His Heaven, all’s right with the world.”1
The thrill and the exultant song celebrating the event are so inspiring that the Rabbis inserted it into the daily liturgy. Shirat haYam, the song of the sea, is recited just before the Barekhu call to prayer. The reference to the sea split is reprised just before the central Amidah (standing, silent) prayers. On weekdays, this is the liturgical point when the worshippers address God directly, asking for their fundamental needs to be met and for the national redemption be realized. This event “confirms” that prayers for redemption are not said in vain. “That day the Lord saved Israel from the hands of the Egyptians… Israel saw the great power the Lord had displayed against the Egyptians. The people feared the Lord. They believed in God and in His servant, Moses” (Exodus 14:31).
The counter-narrative begins immediately. From the Reed Sea, Moses marches the Israelites into the wilderness of Shur. For three days, they find no water sources until they arrive at Marah where the water is bitter and undrinkable. Thereupon the people turn on Moses. At God’s instruction, Moses makes a quick miracle. He takes a branch from a tree which he throws into the spring and the water turns potable (Exodus 15:24-26).
Less than three weeks later, the people arrive in the wilderness of Zin. They become hungry. Again they turn on Moses and Aaron. “If only we had died at the hand of the Lord in Egypt, where we sat by the fleshpots, when we ate our fill of bread.” Instead you two “have brought us out into this wilderness to kill this whole assembly with hunger…” (Exodus 16:2-3). The Lord intervenes with a double barreled miracle. In the evening, flocks of quail cover the campground providing meat for the taking. In the morning, manna—bread from Heaven— floods the desert. People gather all the bread that they can eat. Henceforth, throughout the desert journey, this miracle food will descend daily except on Shabbat.2
At the next campsite, Rephidim, there is no water. The people assail Moses. “Why did you take us out of Egypt? To kill us and our children and our livestock with thirst?” At God’s instruction, Moses strikes a rock. Miraculously, water gushes forth for the whole assembly to drink. This fix works. The people drink their fill and are pacified.
This pattern persists to the very end of the desert trek. At Sinai, the people are overwhelmed with awe and fear of God. Yet when Moses delays coming down from the mountain, the people create a Golden Calf and dance around the idol chanting, “These are your gods, O Israel, which brought you up out of the land of Egypt” (Exodus 32:4).3
On the way after Sinai, the people get bored with the manna. They revolt and complain that they miss all the delicious “cucumbers, melons, leeks, onions and garlic they enjoyed—at no charge!—in Egypt” (Numbers 11:5). God responds by giving them unlimited amounts of quail until they are sick of it (Numbers 11:20).
The dead end of this roller coaster trek comes when the spies return from surveilling Canaan.4 The people panic and they propose to return to Egypt at once. This mutiny is put down by another divine appearance and punishment. The pattern of miracles followed by relapses does not change until God acknowledges that the ex-slaves will never be able to function as free people. They must die in the desert.5 Only the new generation, raised in freedom and taught Torah by Moses and Aaron, is up to the challenge of winning a homeland and creating a free society.
As our parashah shows, even visible miracles have only a fleeting, surface effect. Why is this so? Because miracles are external experiences that do not change the underlying psychology of the people who witness them. When the miracle is unbelievably powerful—such as at the Reed Sea—people are thunderstruck. They really do believe in God and Moses—momentarily. But three days later, the dazzle has faded. Then the slaves, unaccustomed to the hard work and responsibility taking of the life of freedom, grow tired. They are frightened that the dependable—if meager±slaves’ provisions are not there.
Yielding to a miracle is like giving in to intimidation. Since the person did not really want to do it, the preferred alternative behavior reasserts itself as soon as one can get away with it. When the fear (or the thrill) instilled by a miracle fades, the ingrained tendencies or the habitual behavior patterns take over. The individuals go on their way, not the “coerced” divine way.
The deepest message in our parashah is in its opening declaration that Moses did not take the short route to Israel (i.e. the King’s highway via the Land of the Philistines) because the Israelite slaves were not up to the challenges of fighting a war to win their freedom (Exodus 13:17). At that point, there were two choices before God. One, to remove human free will and turn the Israelites and ultimately all human beings into robots, perfectly fulfilling God’s directions and not deterred by real-life considerations. Maimonides wrote that out of respect for human beings, God chooses the second option, to accept people as they are. Rather than changing human nature miraculously, the Torah accepts the realities of human nature and human limitations.6 God enters with them into a covenantal relationship in which the Israelites are asked to raise the level of their moral performance above the society and culture around them, while moving toward an ultimately higher divine standard.7
The Bible’s ultimate process is a movement away from visible miracles and public (heavenly) revelation toward a process of education and persuasion to get people to act properly. Increasingly, the historical outcomes are dependent on human behavior and the equilibrium of forces rather than on divine intervention.8 By the time we reach the Talmud, the Rabbis tell us that the age of prophecy (direct messages from Heaven) and of visible miracles is over. Such miracles are too “coercive.” God wants humans to use their reason and emotions and choose to do the right thing out of free will and choice.9
This shift in tactics explains the fate of idolatry among Jews. Idolatry persisted in the biblical age despite the Torah’s full scale war on it. Even remarkable miracles, such as Elijah’s triumph over the prophets of Baal, won only temporary victories.10 In the Rabbinic period when there were no such dramatic divine interventions, the Rabbis overcame idolatry completely by universally educating the people with talmud Torah. They raised the people’s level of cultural and philosophical sophistication and won the battle by transforming people’s consciousness. If you will forgive the pun: Splitting the Reed Sea made a great splash, but immersion in the sea of talmudic learning transformed people for the better.
1 Robert Browning, Pippa’s Song, Act I.
2 No problem, a two day size portion descends every Friday.
3 See generally Exodus chapters 31-33.
4 See Numbers 13.
5 See chapter 14.
6 Maimonides, Guide of the Perplexed, Part 3, 32.
7 Entering the covenant and applying its standards to daily life and historical challenges is the substance of the next two parashiyot, Yitro and Mishpatim, and will be analyzed in the next two divrei Torah.
8 See the description of this development in Richard E. Friedman, The Disappearance of God: A Divine Mystery, (Little: Brown, 1995).
9 See Talmud Shabbat 88a, “Kafah aleihem har k’gigit” and Tosafot, s.v. "moda’ah rabba l’oraita.”
10 Compare Elijah’s miraculous defeat of the Baal idolators (I Kings 18) with the later behavior of King Ahab and Queen Jezebel (chapters 20-21).
(31) And when Israel saw the wondrous power which the LORD had wielded against the Egyptians, the people feared the LORD; they had faith in the LORD and His servant Moses.
(ב) וכמו זאת ההנהגה בעצמה מן המנהיג ההוא ית' באו דברים רבים בתורתנו - והוא שאי אפשר לצאת מן ההפך אל ההפך פתאום - ולזה אי אפשר לפי טבע האדם שיניח כל מה שהרגיל בו פתאום. וכאשר שלח האלוה 'משה רבנו' לתתנו "ממלכת כהנים וגוי קדוש" בידיעתו ית' - כמו שבאר ואמר "אתה הראת לדעת וגו'" וידעת היום והשבות אל לבבך וגו'" ולהנתן לעבודתו - כמו שאמר "ולעבדו בכל לבבכם" ואמר "ועבדתם את יי אלוקיכם" ואמר "ואותו תעבודו" - והיה המנהג המפורסם בעולם כולו שהיו אז רגילים בו והעבודה הכוללת אשר גדלו עליה - להקריב מיני בעלי חיים בהיכלות ההם אשר היו מעמידים בהם הצלמים ולהשתחוות להם ולקטר לפניהם והעבודים והפרושים היו אז האנשים הנתונים לעבודת ההיכלות ההם העשויים לכוכבים (כמו שבארנו) - לא גזרה חכמתו ית' ותחבולתו המבוארת בכל בריאותיו שיצונו להניח מיני העבודות ההם כולם ולעזבם ולבטלם כי אז היה זה מה שלא יעלה בלב לקבלו כפי טבע האדם שהוא נוטה תמיד למורגל; והיה דומה אז כאילו יבוא נביא בזמננו זה שיקרא לעבודת האלוה ויאמר האלוה צוה אתכם שלא תתפללו אליו ולא תצומו ולא תבקשו תשועתו בעת צרה אבל תהיה עבודתכם מחשבה מבלתי מעשה: ומפני זה השאיר ית' מיני העבודות ההם והעתיקם מהיותם לנבראים ולענינים דמיוניים שאין אמיתות להם - לשמו ית' וצונו לעשותם לו ית'. וצוונו לבנות היכל לו "ועשו לי מקדש" ושיהיה המזבח לשמו "מזבח אדמה תעשה לי" ושיהיה הקרבן לו "אדם כי יקריב מכם קרבן ליי" ושישתחוו לו ושיקטירוהו לפניו. והזהיר מעשות דבר מאלו המעשים לזולתו "זובח לאלוקים יחרם וגו'" "כי לא תשתחוה לאל אחר". והפריש 'כהנים' לבית ה'מקדש' ואמר "וכהנו לי" וחיב שייוחדו להם מתנות על כל פנים שיספיקו להם מפני שהם עסוקים בבית ובקרבנותיו והם מתנות ה'לוים וה'כהנים'. והגיע בזאת הערמה האלוקית שנמחוה זכר 'עבודה זרה' והתקימה הפינה הגדולה האמיתית באמונתו והיא מציאות האלוה ואחדותו; ולא יברחו הנפשות וישתוממו בבטל העבודות אשר הורגלו ולא נודעו עבודתו זולתם: ואני יודע שנפשך תברח מזה הענין בהכרח בתחילת מחשבה ויכבד עליך ותשאלני בלבך ותאמר לי איך יבואו מצוות ואזהרות ופעולות עצומות ומבוארות מאד והושם להם זמנים והם כולם בלתי מכוונות לעצמם אבל הם מפני דבר אחר כאילו הם תחבולה שעשה העלוה לנו להגיע אל כונתו הראשונה? ואי זה מונע היה אצלו ית' לצוות לנו כונתו הראשונה ויתן בנו יכולת לקבלה ולא היה צורך לאלו אשר חשבת שהם על צד הכונה השניה? - שמע תשובתי אשר תסיר מלבך זה החלי ותגלה לך אמיתת מה שעוררתיך עליו. והוא שכבר בא ב'תורה' כמו זה הענין בשוה - והוא אמרו "ולא נחם אלוקים דרך ארץ פלישתים כי קרוב הוא וגו' ויסב אלוקים את העם דרך המדבר ים סוף". וכמו שהסב האלוה אותם מן הדרך הישרה אשר היתה מכוונת תחלה מפני יראת מה שלא היו גופותם יכולים לסבלו לפי הטבע אל דרך אחרת עד שתגיע הכונה הראשונה - כן צוה בזאת המצוה אשר זכרנו מפני יראת מה שאין יכולת לנפש לקבלו לפי הטבע שתגיע הכונה הראשונה והיא - השגתו ית' והנחת 'עבודה זרה'. כי כמו שאין בטבע האדם שיגדל על מלאכת עבדות בחומר ובלבנים והדומה להם ואחר כן ירחץ ידיו לשעתו מלכלוכם וילחם עם 'ילידי הענק' פתאום כן אין בטבעו שיגדל על מינים רביםמן העבודות ומעשים מורגלים שכבר נטו אליהם הנפשות עד ששבו כמושכל ראשון ויניחם כולם פתאום. וכמו שהיה מחכמת האלוה להסב אותם במדבר עד שילמדו גבורה - כמו שנודע שההליכה במדבר ומעוט הנאות הגוף מרחיצה וסיכה וכיוצא בהם יולידו הגבורה והפכם יוליד רוך לב - ונולדו גם כן אנשים שלא הרגילו בשפלות ובעבדות וכל זה היה במצות אלוקיות על ידי משה רבינו' "על פי יי יחנו ועל פי יי יסעו - את משמרת יי שמרו על פי יי ביד משה" - כן בא זה החלק מן התורה בתחבולה אלוקית עד שישארו עם מין המעשה המורגל כדי שתעלה בידם האמונה אשר היא הכונה הראשונה. ושאלתך "אי זה מונע היה לאלוה מצוותנו כונתו הראשונה ויתן לנו יכולת לקבלה?" תחיב זאת השאלה השנית ויאמר לך ואי זה מונע היה לאלוה שינחם 'דרך ארץ פלישתים' ויתן להם יכולת להלחם ולא היה צריך לזה הסיבוב ב"עמוד הענן יומם ועמוד האש לילה"? וכן תחיב שאלה שלישית - על סיבת היעודים הטובים אשר יעד על שמירת המצוות והיעודים הרעים אשר יעד על העברות ויאמר לך אחר שכונת האלוה הראשונה ורצונו היה שנאמין זאת התורה ונעשה ככל הכתוב בה למה לא נתן לנו יכולת לקבלה ולעשותה תמיד ולא היה עושה לנו תחבולה להיטיב לנו אם נעבדהו ולהנקם ממנו אם נמרהו? ולעשות הטובות ההם כולם והנקמות ההם כולם? - כי זאת גם כן תחבולה שעשה האלוה לנו עד שיגיע ממנו אל כונתו הראשונה - ואי זה מונע היה אצלו לתת רצון במעשי העבודה אשר רצה וריחוק העברות אשר מאסם טבע מוטבע בנו?: והתשובה על אלו השאלות השלש וכל מה שהוא ממינם - תשובה אחת כוללת והיא שהאותות כולם אף על פי שהם שינוי טבע איש אחד מאישי הנמצאות אך טבע בני אדם לא ישנהו האלוה כלל על צד המופת. ומפני זה השורש הגדול אמר "מי יתן והיה לבבם זה להם וגו'" ומפני זה באה המצוה והאזהרה והגמול והעונש. וכבר בארנו זאת הפינה במופתיה במקומות רבים מחיבורינו. ולא אמרתי זה מפני שאני מאמין ששינוי טבע כל אחד מבני אדם קשה עליו ית' אך הוא אפשר ונופל תחת היכולת אלא שהוא לא רצה כלל לעשות זה ולא ירצהו לעולם כפי הפינות התוריות; ואילו היה מרצונו לשנות טבע כל איש מבני אדם למה שירצהו ית' מן האיש ההוא היה בטל שליחות הנביאים ונתינת התורה כולה:
(2) Many precepts in our Law are the result of a similar course adopted by the same Supreme Being. It is, namely, impossible to go suddenly from one extreme to the other: it is therefore according to the nature of man impossible for him suddenly to discontinue everything to which he has been accustomed. Now God sent Moses to make [the Israelites] a kingdom of priests and a holy nation (Exod. 19:6) by means of the knowledge of God. Comp. "Unto thee it was showed that thou mightest know that the Lord is God (Deut. 4:35); "Know therefore this day, and consider it in thine heart, that the Lord is God" (ibid. 5:39). The Israelites were commanded to devote themselves to His service; comp. "and to serve him with all your heart" (ibid. 11:13); "and you shall serve the Lord your God" (Exod. 23:25); "and ye shall serve him" (Deut. 13:5). But the custom which was in those days general among all men, and the general mode of worship in which the Israelites were brought up, consisted in sacrificing animals in those temples which contained certain images, to bow down to those images, and to burn incense before them; religious and ascetic persons were in those days the persons that were devoted to the service in the temples erected to the stars, as has been explained by us. It was in accordance with the wisdom and plan of God, as displayed in the whole Creation, that He did not command us to give up and to discontinue all these manners of service; for to obey such a commandment it would have been contrary to the nature of man, who generally cleaves to that to which he is used; it would in those days have made the same impression as a prophet would make at present if he called us to the service of God and told us in His name, that we should not pray to Him, not fast, not seek His help in time of trouble; that we should serve Him in thought, and not by any action. For this reason God allowed these kinds of service to continue; He transferred to His service that which had formerly served as a worship of created beings, and of things imaginary and unreal, and commanded us to serve Him in the same manner; viz., to build unto Him a temple; comp. "And they shall make unto me a sanctuary" (Exod. 25:8); to have the altar erected to His name; comp. "An altar of earth thou shalt make unto me" (ibid. 20:21); to offer the sacrifices to Him; comp. "If any man of you bring an offering unto the Lord" (Lev. 1:2), to bow down to Him and to burn incense before Him. He has forbidden to do any of these things to any other being; comp. "He who sacrificeth unto any God, save the Lord only, he shall be utterly destroyed" (Exod. 22:19); "For thou shalt bow down to no other God" (ibid. 34:14). He selected priests for the service in the temple; comp. "And they shall minister unto me in the priest's office" (ibid. 28:41). He made it obligatory that certain gifts, called the gifts of the Levites and the priests, should be assigned to them for their maintenance while they are engaged in the service of the temple and its sacrifices. By this Divine plan it was effected that the traces of idolatry were blotted out, and the truly great principle of our faith, the Existence and Unity of God, was firmly established; this result was thus obtained without deterring or confusing the minds of the people by the abolition of the service to which they were accustomed and which alone was familiar to them. I know that you will at first thought reject this idea and find it strange; you will put the following question to me in your heart: How can we suppose that Divine commandments, prohibitions, and important acts, which are fully explained, and for which certain seasons are fixed, should not have been commanded for their own sake, but only for the sake of some other thing: as if they were only the means which He employed for His primary object? What prevented Him from making His primary object a direct commandment to us, and to give us the capacity of obeying it? Those precepts which in your opinion are only the means and not the object would then have been unnecessary. Hear my answer, which win cure your heart of this disease and will show you the truth of that which I have pointed out to you. There occurs in the Law a passage which contains exactly the same idea; it is the following: "God led them not through the way of the land of the Philistines, although that was near; for God said, Lest peradventure the people repent when they see war, and they return to Egypt; but God led the people about, through the way of the wilderness of the Red Sea," etc. (Exod. 13:17). Here God led the people about, away from the direct road which He originally intended, because He feared they might meet on that way with hardships too great for their ordinary strength; He took them by another road in order to obtain thereby His original object. In the same manner God refrained from prescribing what the people by their natural disposition would be incapable of obeying, and gave the above-mentioned commandments as a means of securing His chief object, viz., to spread a knowledge of Him [among the people], and to cause them to reject idolatry. It is contrary to man's nature that he should suddenly abandon all the different kinds of Divine service and the different customs in which he has been brought up, and which have been so general, that they were considered as a matter of course; it would be just as if a person trained to work as a slave with mortar and bricks, or similar things, should interrupt his work, clean his hands, and at once fight with real giants. It was the result of God's wisdom that the Israelites were led about in the wilderness till they acquired courage. For it is a well-known fact that travelling in the wilderness, and privation of bodily enjoyments, such as bathing, produce courage, whilst the reverse is the source of faint-heartedness: besides, another generation rose during the wanderings that had not been accustomed to degradation and slavery. All the travelling in the wilderness was regulated by Divine commands through Moses; comp. "At the commandment of the Lord they rested, and at the commandment of the Lord they journeyed; they kept the charge of the Lord and the commandment of the Lord by the hand of Moses" (Num. 9:23). In the same way the portion of the Law under discussion is the result of divine wisdom, according to which people are allowed to continue the kind of worship to which they have been accustomed, in order that they might acquire the true faith, which is the chief object [of God's commandments]. You ask, What could have prevented God from commanding us directly, that which is the chief object, and from giving us the capacity of obeying it? This would lead to a second question, What prevented God from leading the Israelites through the way of the land of the Philistines, and endowing them with strength for fighting? The leading about by a pillar of cloud by day and a pillar of fire by night would then not have been necessary. A third question would then be asked in reference to the good promised as reward for the keeping of the commandments, and the evil foretold as a punishment for sins. It is the following question: As it is the chief object and purpose of God that we should believe in the Law, and act according to that which is written therein, why has He not given us the capacity of continually believing in it, and following its guidance, instead of holding out to us reward for obedience, and punishment for disobedience, or of actually giving all the predicted reward and punishment? For [the promises and the threats] are but the means of leading to this chief object. What prevented Him from giving us, as part of our nature, the will to do that which He desires us to do, and to abandon the kind of worship which He rejects? There is one general answer to these three questions, and to all questions of the same character: it is this: Although in every one of the signs [related in Scripture] the natural property of some individual being is changed, the nature of man is never changed by God by way of miracle. It is in accordance with this important principle that God said, "O that there were such an heart in them, that they would fear me," etc. (Deut. 5:26). It is also for this reason that He distinctly stated the commandments and the prohibitions, the reward and the punishment. This principle as regards miracles has been frequently explained by us in our works: I do not say this because I believe that it is difficult for God to change the nature of every individual person; on the contrary, it is possible, and it is in His power, according to the principles taught in Scripture; but it has never been His will to do it, and it never will be. If it were part of His will to change [at His desire] the nature of any person, the mission of prophets and the giving of the Law would have been altogether superfluous.