What is the נקודה of wronging that gives one the name of רמאי ? רשע?
עצמות יוסף-
מהרש״ל-
מאירי-
We were מדייק from תוס׳ ד״ה לקידושי that he holds the רמאות is something else. What is it acc. to תוס׳. What is the דיוק ? What is the opinion of תוס׳ ?
According to תוס׳ this seems to be something unique to these first few cases, we need to figure out what is it then that gives one the title רשע like we find in the last two cases.
Start תוס׳ ד״ה עני , learn until ומיהו
תוס׳ has two proofs that you would not be called a רשע if you take a הפקר item that someone else was pursuing
Learn just the question in the תוס׳ הרא״ש
Why does the תוס׳ הרא״ש leave out the first גמ׳ ?
How would you explain the two גמ׳ to defend רש״י ?
Learn the רש״ש ( found in the back of your גמ׳ )
Learn the תוס׳ הרי״ד
עצמות יוסף-
מהרש״ל-
מאירי-
We were מדייק from תוס׳ ד״ה לקידושי that he holds the רמאות is something else. What is it acc. to תוס׳. What is the דיוק ? What is the opinion of תוס׳ ?
According to תוס׳ this seems to be something unique to these first few cases, we need to figure out what is it then that gives one the title רשע like we find in the last two cases.
Start תוס׳ ד״ה עני , learn until ומיהו
תוס׳ has two proofs that you would not be called a רשע if you take a הפקר item that someone else was pursuing
Learn just the question in the תוס׳ הרא״ש
Why does the תוס׳ הרא״ש leave out the first גמ׳ ?
How would you explain the two גמ׳ to defend רש״י ?
Learn the רש״ש ( found in the back of your גמ׳ )
Learn the תוס׳ הרי״ד